Program

Education Doctorate

Number of Pages

127

Year Approved

2026

First Advisor

Melanie Keilor

Second Reader

Barry Sullivan

Third Reader

Marta Shaw

Abstract

This qualitative study examined the lived experiences of middle school teachers in the era of smartphones in the classroom. Through in-depth interviews with 20 middle school teachers from various school districts, each with three or more years of teaching experience, the study identified the following themes: disrupted classroom, volatile classroom, the toll of digital dependency, the mandate for uniformity, the integrity of enforcement, the friction of resistance, benefits experienced, the cycle of confrontation, the parental paradox, and the path of least resistance. Teachers highlighted that these distractions pose significant challenges for educators, affecting the learning environment and teacher well-being. They stressed the need for a consistent, school-wide smartphone policy with uniform enforcement and strong administrative backing. The findings revealed that teachers' real experiences with smartphones are characterized by systemic stagnation, with the classroom becoming a disjointed, sometimes unpredictable space. Teachers must navigate an environment where instructional flow is often disrupted by digital distractions and where devices frequently lead to cycles of conflict. The most important step schools should take is to adopt structural solutions such as magnetic pouches, bag-and-tag systems, or centralized lockers. Removing the device from the student's possession before class begins breaks the cycle of confrontation and prevents the manipulation that occurs when students are asked to store it in their pockets or backpacks—eliminating the individual teacher as the main enforcer and having all teachers enforce the rule.

Degree Name

Education Doctorate

Document Type

Doctoral dissertation

Terms of Use and License Information

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 International License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 International License.

Included in

Education Commons

Share

COinS